Hamlet’s family is undoubtedly
deemed as a dysfunctional family while compared to Laertes’s family.
Shakespeare deliberately juxtaposes both Hamlet’s and Laertes’s families in
hopes of exemplifying the constructive advice between Ophelia and Hamlet:
Polonius and Laertes offer advice to Ophelia in order to protect her wellbeing
while Claudius, the king, offers advice in order to protect his selfish
wellbeing.
The relationship between Hamlet and
Claudius can be thoroughly understood through the apparent disconnection
between the two. Amidst their conversation regarding Hamlet’s possible
education in Wittenberg, Claudius attempts to rationalize his reasoning not to
worry about Hamlet’s father’s death by explaining that maintaining high energy
of emotions “is a course / of impious stubbornness. ‘Tis unmanly grief” (Hamlet I.ii.96-98). In truthfulness, Claudius’s
rationalization behind Hamlet’s grief is a mere attempt to make Hamlet
understand that Denmark’s success, as a state, will only be beneficial with the
presence of Hamlet. If Hamlet leaves for Wittenberg, his departure will
completely reflect the change of power in the state. Claudius now holds power
instead of Hamlet’s father. Hamlet’s departure will yield a loss of power and
trust within the entire state and more importantly to Hamlet’s family.
Shakespeare deliberately contrasts
Hamlet’s family to Laertes’s family in order to highlight the caring, selfless
attitudes both Laertes and Polonius have towards Ophelia. Although Laertes
originally warns Ophelia of Hamlet’s wrongful feelings towards her, Shakespeare
deliberately incorporates another voice by including Polonius into Ophelia’s
wellbeing. By including Polonius as Laertes leaves, Laertes exclaims that “A
double blessing is a double grace. / Occasion smiles upon a second leave” (Hamlet I.iii.57-58). Both Laertes and
Polonius denounce Hamlet’s attraction to Ophelia in order to sincerely protect
her wellbeing. Unlike Claudius’s selfishness, Laertes and Polonius give advice
with the least amount of selfishness possible. Polonius, unlike Claudius,
allows Laertes to depart for his journey to France by stating “The wind sits in
the shoulder of your sail, / And you are stayed for. There, my blessing with /
thee” (Hamlet I.iii.61-63). The fact
that Polonius allows Laertes to depart while Claudius does not exemplifies how
Claudius is holding Hamlet down in order to benefit only himself. Laertes’s
family, in comparison to Hamlet’s family, undoubtedly exceeds in the selfless
words of advice whereas Hamlet’s family (particularly Claudius) is heavily
undermined by Claudius’s selfishness.
No comments:
Post a Comment